- Strength Framework
- Posts
- How To Properly Bulk. An Evidence Based Approach
How To Properly Bulk. An Evidence Based Approach
Bulking season is well underway, eating whatever you want is a sure fire way to add just as much fat as muscle. Science has some direction for us, suggesting the slower the better.
IN TODAY’S ISSUE
How To Properly Bulk. An Evidence Based Approach.
What’s your go to when you bulk? Dirty bro bulk? MADCOW? Copy what Sam Sulek eats? Or perhaps you eat “clean” and your soul borderline die inside with kilos of broccoli, rice and chicken.
Perhaps you have been yoyo dieting between bulking and cutting as you gain much more fat than you’re comfortable with and never really bulk long enough to add some real quality muscle mass?
At the end of the day, it comes down to calories in vs calories out, but what about where your calories come from and how quickly you gain weight? Can we limit the amount of fat gain during a bulk?
What You'll Find Out
A MESSAGE FROM OUR PARTNER
Fuel Your Ambitions
40g protein, plus 27 essential vitamins & minerals
Ready in 30 seconds – just shake, sip, go
New customers get 15% off with code BEHUEL15
WHAT’S UP
Body Recomposition & Optimizing For Muscle Growth
Firstly, it is possible to grow muscle (perhaps not increase overall body weight) in a slight calorie deficit or at maintenance calories, referred to as Body Recomposition. This is where you gain muscle and lose fat at the same time.
Certain parameters need to be met in order to achieve this, and although this typically works best for beginners or detrained experienced lifters, it is possible to achieve in trained individuals (Barakat et al., 2020) - Strength and Conditioning Journal.
Despite the common belief that building muscle and losing fat at the same time is only plausible in novice/obese individuals, the literature provided supports that trained individuals can also experience body recomposition.
Individuals' training status, the exercise interventions, and their baseline body composition can influence the magnitude of muscle gained and fat lost.
In addition, there seems to be confounding non-training/nutrition variables such as sleep, hormones, and metabolism that can significantly influence these adaptations.
Although body recomposition may sound appealing and might just be what you're looking for, you will never build as much muscle during body recomposition as you would taking the time to do a proper bulk.
Optimizing Muscle Growth
Food is fuel for our bodies at the end of the day, so the more food the better right? The main problem with the classic bro “dirty bulk” - while they may help add slabs of muscle with the huge amount excess calories, this route will also add quite a lot of fat onto your frame in the process. This results in most people yoyo dieting between bulking and cutting too frequently and never really getting anywhere.
Now, some fat gain will happen, but the more fat gain we can limit while optimizing muscle growth the better.
The quicker you gain weight, through an overconsumption of calories higher than what is required to begin to increase weight, the higher the percentage of that weight will come from an increase in fat as opposed to muscle (Garthe et al., 2013).
A MESSAGE FROM NIKE
Conquer Winter in Style: Best Men’s Sneakers from Nike Air Max.
Winter is here, and it’s time to elevate your look while staying warm and comfortable. The Nike Air Max collection is perfect for the modern man ready to tackle the season. From the edgy Air Max Plus to the versatile AM1, these sneakers combine style with features designed to keep your feet happy all winter long.
Whether you're tackling holiday shopping or celebrating with friends, these kicks are your perfect companion. Find your ideal pair and effortlessly elevate your winter wardrobe this season.
Treat yourself or a loved one to a stylish pair from the collection this holiday season.
SCIENCE BRO
The Most Important Macronutrient.
If your here and reading this article, you should already be aware of the importance of Protein consumption on muscle growth and recovery.
Having a high protein diet has been shown to preserve muscle in a cutting phase, and this randomised controlled trial by (Campbell et al., 2018) found a positive response to having a high protein diet when in a calorie surplus on body composition. The 8 week trial involved 17 aspiring female physique athletes, who were split into a higher protein (2.5g per kg of bodyweight per day) or lower protein group (0.9g per kg of bodyweight per day).
The high protein group were in a ~400 kcal daily surplus, created wholly through increased protein intake. After the 8 week resistance training and dietary intervention, the authors of the study found FFM (Fat free mass) to have increased significantly more in the high protein group (+~2.1kg) vs the lower protein group (+~0.6kg). They also found FM (Fat mass) decreased over time in the higher protein group (-1.1kg) but no significant change was observed in the lower protein group.
Although this trial compared high protein vs lower protein, the current body of evidence has found that 1.6g-2g/kg of bodyweight per day to be the optimal protein intake for muscle growth and recovery. So having a protein intake as high as 2.5g/kg may not be necessary, but the stark contrast in results vs a lower intake of under 1g/kg per day should highlight the importance of intaking sufficient high quality protein and not just binge eating doughnuts to get enough calories in when it comes to adding FFM.
SCIENCE BRO #2
How Big A Calorie Surplus & How Fast Should You Bulk?
A pilot study by (Ribeiro et al., 2019b) which included 11 amature male bodybuilders, who trained 6 times per week for 4 weeks were split into two groups, one group (G1) consumed a higher energy intake while the other group (G2) consumed a moderate energy intake.
The results? G1 (the higher intake group) was the only group to find a significant body fat increase from the intervention (G1 - +7.4% vs G2 - 0.8%). For muscle mass, G1 seen more muscle growth than G2 (2.7% vs 1.1%).
So although you would gain 1.1% more muscle, it’s personal preference if that’s worth the extra 6.4% increase in body fat.
You can see the results in the chart in figure A, from the study below:
Figure A From: (Ribeiro et al., 2019b)
A study by (Smith et al., 2021), had 21 resistance trained males take part in a 6 week intervention, taking a daily high calorie protein and carbohydrate supplement with the goal of gaining roughly 0.45kg per week.
The studies authors found that on average a total body weight gain of ~0.55% per week resulting in almost all gains being in FFM (Fat Free Mass).
TL:DR
Key Takeaways & Practical Applications
The body of evidence shows that a slower rate of bulking to be beneficial at increasing lean muscle mass while limiting fat gain. Looking at the study results on trained competitive bodybuilders by (Ribeiro et al., 2019b). I wouldn’t consider the extra 1.6% increase in muscle mass to be worth the 7.4% increase in fat mass as opposed to just 0.8% increase.
Body Recomposition is possible, and you can build muscle this way, however it is not optimal for muscle growth.
Ensuring you consume a high protein diet can aid in the desired effect of increased muscle mass (FFM) and limit fat mass increase.
Although the study used protein intakes as high as 2.5g per kg of bodyweight, the current body of literature has found 1.6g-2g per kg of bodyweight to be sufficient.
A slower rate of body mass increase is optimal for increasing muscle mass without needlessly increasing fat mass (however may not eliminate fat mass increase)
Aim for a smaller calorie surplus over your maintenance calories, the study above found 0.55% per week to result in almost all FFM gain. The general stance in the evidence based fitness community is 1-2% per month.
Building muscle takes time, you can’t feed your muscles to grow, trying to do this will just result in excess fat gain.
Figure out how much your maintenance calories are, and go slightly over them. A simple way to get this started is to add a surplus of 250 kcals or 10% of your maintenance calories per day. Begin to track your bodyweight and aim for 1-2% increase per month.
That’s it for today ✌️
If you have any questions you’d like answered, topics you would like discussed, or perhaps some feedback, email them over to me at: [email protected]
For more updates: 👉 Facebook Page & Instagram
Don’t Keep Us A Secret
If you found this helpful, share the email with friends & spread the word.
If this was sent to you and you’d like to receive next week’s issue, join the 2.1K others who read us weekly and sign up here 👉 Sign Up
Reply